Home » News » Can You Copyright News Headlines?

Can You Copyright News Headlines?

This article addresses the law relating to copyright in news headlines and explores the case law relating to whether media publishers can protect their headlines as original literary works.

Media companies have tried to claim copyright protection over newspaper headlines reproduced on the internet. News publishers have claimed that news headlines qualify for copyright protection as original literary works under copyright legislation. As early as 1918 in the case of International News Service v Associated Press 248 US 215 the US Supreme Court has held that there can be no copyright in facts or 'news of the day'.

However unlike in Commonwealth countries like Australia where there is no recognition of a tort of misappropriation the United States recognises a doctrine of misappropriation of hot news. This tort has enabled media publishers and other organisations to gain the right to protect other entities from publishing certain 'facts' or data, including news and other time-sensitive information during a certain window period to enable the organisation which has invested in gathering the data can recoup their investment. There are a number of criteria which must be satisfied to prevail in an action of hot news misappropriation

As stated above, Commonwealth Courts have rejected a tort of unfair competition as framed in the United States and have decided such cases solely on the basis of copyright law. Courts have been reluctant to afford literary copyright to titles, characters and news headlines. However newspaper publishers have only recently brought legal action in Australia for copyright infringement in their headlines and portions of their articles on the basis that the reproduction or abstracting of headlines is equivalent to theft of their content. Newspaper publishers have tried to obtain copyright protection in their headlines as discrete original literary works under copyright legislation.

For copyright protection to exist a literary work must exist and not every piece of writing or printing will constitute a literary work within the meaning of the law.

Typically, single words, short phrases, advertising slogans, characters and news headlines have been refused copyright protection even where they have been invented or newly coined by an author. The courts have given different reasons for denying copyright protection to such works. One reason offered by the Courts is that the 'works' are too trivial or not substantial enough to qualify for copyright protection. The case of Exxon Corporation v Exxon Insurance Consultants Ltd (1981) 3 All ER 241 is a leading English precedent where copyright was refused for the word Exxon as an original literary work.

Exxon argued it enjoyed copyright in the word Exxon having invested time and energy in employing linguists to invent the word, contending that the actual size of the literary work does not preclude a work from acquiring copyright protection. The court found that the work was too short or slight to amount to a copyright work.

The Court also stated that although the word was invented and original it had no particular meaning, comparing it with the word 'Jabberwocky' used for Lewis Carroll's famous poem. US case law has only recognised limited intellectual property rights in invented names or fictional characters in exceptional cases. There is no modern English or Australian case which has recognised that titles, phrases, song and book titles should be granted copyright protection.

Publishers asserting copyright in headlines contend that compiling and arresting headlines involves a high degree of novelty and creativity, and that headlines should qualify as original literary works. To be a literary work, a work has to convey pleasure or afford enjoyment or instruction. A literary work must also be original, and to satisfy the test of originality it must be original not just in the sense of originating from an identifiable author rather than copied, but also original in the particular form of expression in which an author conveys ideas or information. This is because copyright is not meant to protect facts or ideas.

The question whether copyright can subsist in newspaper headlines was discussed briefly by a Judge in a Scottish case called Shetland Times Ltd v Wills [1997] FSH 604. The Judge did not arrive at a final conclusion as to whether a newspaper headline can be a literary work, but expressed reservations about granting copyright to headlines, especially where they only provide a brief indication of the subject matter of the items they refer to in an article.

Newspaper headlines are similar in nature to titles of a book or other works and titles, slogans and short phrases which have been refused copyright protection. In the case of IceTV Pty Ltd v Nine Network Australia Pty Ltd [2009] HCA 14, the High Court held that no copyright can subsist in a programme title alone. The Courts have based their reasons for refusing copyright protection to such works both of the basis that they are too short (see Francis Day & Hunter Ltd v Twentieth Century Fox Corp Ltd (194) AC 112) or alternatively that titles of newspapers, songs, magazines, books, single words and advertising slogans lack sufficient originality to attract copyright protection.

The title 'Opportunity Knocks' for a game show was refused protection, as was the title "The Man who Broke the Bank at Monte Carlo" for a song and "Splendid Misery" for a novel. Courts have also refused copyright protection for invented names such as Kojak and newspaper titles such as 'The Mirror'. Such titles and names may however be protected by other forms of intellectual property such as trademark law or the tort of passing off.

Whilst Courts have recognised that newspaper headlines may involve creative flair and be clever and engaging but represent little more than the fact or idea conveyed.

Fairfax Media Publications Pty Ltd v Reed International Books Australia Pty Ltd the Federal Court of Australia has ruled that newspaper headlines are not capable of copyright protection. Reed and collected and reproduced the news headlines and articles appearing in the Australian Financial Review on it's Abix subscription service. Fairfax alleged that by producing abstracts of the articles in their service Reed had infringed the copyright in a number of works, being the headlines as a separate literary work and in the headline and article together, as a 'combination work', all of the articles , headlines and bylines as a 'compilation' and also published edition copyright in each of the Australian Financial Review. The Court held that the headline was too trivial to be copyrightable and did not amount to a substantial part of the combination work so as to amount to infringement and the combination work did not amount to a work of joint authorship.

The law in the United States is somewhat unsettled in relation to the rights of news aggreggators to engage in such activity due to the existence of the tort of unfair competition which is recognised in some US States.

The Court held that even had the use amounted to infringement it would have been excused by the defence of fair dealing.


Source by Adele A Pace

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

Our Sponsor Partner - Get Free WordPress Themes,Plugins | Viral Videos,Trending News,Trending Photos on Social Media
Other Popular Google Search Keywords ted bundy, rasputin, john wayne gacy, munchkin cat, ed gein, richard ramirez, dad jokes, life hacks, cannibal holocaust, albert fish, funny cats, omg, black knight satellite, bored panda, creepy, jiggers, mustard gas, bobbit worm, ermine, funny puns, brazilian wandering spider, rodney alcala, robert wadlow, scary pictures, kltv, potoo, stupid jokes, shaved bear, blackhead removal, stupid people, cute pictures, johnny gosch, fainting goats, david berkowitz, elephantiasis, richard speck, rust reddit, corgis, pet fox, cute baby animals, horse breeds, black eyed children, dr sandra lee, engrish, weird pictures, spider crab, you had one job, viral, pie in the face game, japanese spider crab, edmund kemper, baked brie, animatronics, couple tattoos, backyard ideas, clawfoot tub, david parker ray, walmart people, dog shaming, couples tattoos, baby hedgehog, mary bell, regina kay walters, domesticated fox, megamouth shark, hairless bear, porcelain dolls, irena sendler, mug shots, pawslikeme, autocorrect fails, scaphism, face paint, baltic sea anomaly, carl panzram, mole cricket, funny fails, hope for paws, colleen stan, eye tattoo, murderpedia, potoo bird, blanche monnier, blanche monnier, armin meiwes, aww, girl in the box, codex gigas, codex gigas, sylvia likens, lifehack, fordite, dr. pimple popper, munchkin cats, famous serial killers, mimic octopus, vet ranch, irony examples, irony examples, dahmer, reddit creepy, drawings of people, devil's breath, a113, pictures of animals, voyager 2, catio, people die when they are killed, bratz dolls, boomslang, mantidfly, horsehair worm, female demon names, air freshener, ramirez, pet raccoon, look who got busted, cute snake, cute snake, roanoke craigslist, useless facts, useless facts, centralia pennsylvania, google hacks, creepy stories, sea bunny, eyeball tattoo, decapitation, krampus legend, ghost pictures, gloria ramirez, lame jokes, sawney bean, craigslist nova, craigslist nova, craigslist nova, inkbox, emperor nero, boredpanda, spray paint art, passive aggressive notes, passive aggressive notes, viralnova, viralnova, viralnova, viralnova, viralnova, eshima ohashi bridge, photobomb, villalobos rescue center, freddie mercury last photo, brazen bull, brazen bull, the girl in the box, pinterest fail, animatronic, pinterest christmas, deep web stories, coconut crabs, blackhead extractor, cyst popping, guero, albino alligator, starchild, nutmeg high, caracal cat, great potoo, baby owls, dnepropetrovsk maniacs, primordial dwarfism, caught having sex, ghost videos, hiroshima shadows, creepy dolls, lifehacks, cute pigs, facebook fails, awesome tattoos, john gacy, abandoned amusement parks, smallest dog in the world, forced perspective, ed kemper, dr. sandra lee, good deeds, girlfriend meme, june and jennifer gibbons, funny tattoos, the black knight satellite, crazy meme, cool business cards, text fails, examples of irony, reborn babies, gacy, paws like me, lights out short film, cat shaming, chalkboard art, chalkboard art, bad eyebrows, mantid fly, leatherback turtle mouth, lake karachay, goldie hawn age, unique business cards, crazy girlfriend meme, prehistoric animals, derinkuyu, bryan hawn, genie feral child, pun memes, breeding tumblr, eco flower, historical events, unexplained photos, cheerleader fails, life hack, horse running, heaven's gate cult, exotic birds, cat species, kulning, adorable kittens, baby sloths, sectoral heterochromia, scary gifs, scary gifs, creepy drawings, creepy drawings, scary gif, scary gif, how to peel a mango, happy pictures, youngest mother, transabled, internal decapitation, best dad jokes, toynbee tiles, slide carnival, amelia dyer, creepy photos, list of demons, victorian england, dumb people, torture devices, black head removal, best business cards, smallest dog, scary images, leonard lake, army ants, funny mugshots, black eyed kids, unique tattoos, meat glue, unique tattoos, weird stuff, tapetum lucidum, quokka selfie, bloodwood, pupula duplex, pupula duplex, shanty town, wine bottle crafts, blackboard nova, post mortem photography, post mortem photography, hitler's paintings, people at walmart, sad kitten, how to make onion rings, ed gein creations, cat loaf, cat loaf, baby porcupine, raccoon cotton candy, mug cake recipe, bunraku puppet, bunraku puppet, floating bonsai, cute pig, giant weta, baby otters, martin bryant, school bus conversion, ss ourang medan, showerthoughts, cheerleader wardrobe malfunction, easter island bodies, sharpie art, bloodwood tree, cat fails, bloodwood tree, names of demons, cute snakes, acts of kindness, cute snakes, split brain, munchkin kitten, amazing drawings, cool inventions, songs written by prince, clive wearing, real ghost pictures, i drive your truck, birthday dog, birthday dog, tarantula hawk sting, how to make a paper gun, gary heidnik, female demon, turtle without shell, chris porco, mom incest, missile silo, toy box killer, how to fix a broken zipper, cringe gif, the people of walmart, true scary stories, how to make stained glass, pope lick monster, baby wombat, janet hodgson, janet hodgson, creepy gif, creepy gif, tarantula hawk sting, subscription boxes for women, scary animals, secret space program, beautiful horses, megalodon sightings, why are people so stupid, cute pet names, scary stories for kids, the midnight game, fainting goat, angry baby, beer koozies, christmas cats, andreas munzer, overtoun bridge, aztec death whistle, happy images, highway of death, pyura chilensis, animal jokes, jeffrey dahmer fridge contents, animal jokes, faith in humanity restored, franklin castle, mug cakes, heartwarming, upcycling, sarcastically, wral tv, back to the future meme, tattoos for couples, print ads, shark eggs, shark eggs, skull pictures, trap door, broccoli tots, cake fails, cake fails, dad joke, business card ideas, a frightening friend, anime sketches, hover hand, chewbacca dog, wandering spider, fluffy cats, ghost images, human ken doll, scary photos, theanimalrescuesite, death star fire pit, spider goat, real dragon, ww1 facts, barbie jeep, viking berserker, stupid tattoos, stupid tattoos, boomslang snake, jason hawes, cool bedrooms, cat halloween costumes, oddly satisfying, oddly satisfying, small camping trailers, fox pet, funny text fails, china food, wood burning art, baked brie recipe, shiba inus, weird photos, shrek the sheep, hairless animals you won't recognize, yazemeenah rossi, most expensive thing in the world, random fact of the day, awesome inventions, eco flowers, how to open a bottle without a bottle opener, funny snapchats, randall park mall, what do butterflies eat, king and queen tattoos, cutest puppy in the world, tree lobster, creepy quotes, nutty putty cave, hypocrite meme, mini cow, centralia, pennsylvania, zebb quinn, jealous meme, baked brie recipes, weta bug, pig beach, japanese urban legends, happy animals, cool beds, weta bug, jeffrey dahmer fridge, giant spider crab, optical illusions faces, female demons, weepy voiced killer, seph lawless, world war 1 facts, tina watson, baby pangolin, nannie doss, how to clean oven racks, tiny dogs, incest mom, awkward animals, richard ramirez teeth, ted bundy quotes, dump a day, real haunted houses, pet shaming, dump a day, awkward animals, strange pictures, harrison okene, survival shelters, trapdoor, brie recipes, hershey factory, salt and ice challenge, scary drawings, crazy archaeologist, horrible puns, ultrasonic knife, cool lamps, stygiomedusa gigantea, cute corgi, hugs images, wine cork crafts, scary pics, reddit fairy tail, world's smallest dog, velociraptor costume, lauren jessie moss, illusion pictures, luis garavito, baby emu, songs prince wrote, food processor recipes, odessa catacombs, fireworm, dog tattoos, renaissance painting, smallest woman in the world, jessica jones rotten tomatoes, yummy recipes, jigger bug, magnet fishing, cbs news anchors, post-mortem, firefly path, funny dog pics, bagel head, haunted house reactions, mug cake recipes, vicks vapor rub uses, east area rapist, derpy dog, how to pick a lock with a paperclip, betty and barney hill, orangutan magic trick, blackhead extraction, his and hers tattoos, funny horse, real sexting conversations to read, vintage halloween costumes, christine chubbuck reddit,